Leaving Gorgias? The real choice is replacing the Shopify helpdesk, the AI layer, or both. Compare Zendesk, Freshdesk, YourGPT, Chatbase, and Fin on order actions, macros, and pricing.
If you run a Shopify store, Gorgias is one of the few support platforms built so the ticket view carries the order record. That advantage is also why leaving it is fragile. Current pricing is split: a helpdesk subscription based on ticket volume, from 50 to 5,000 tickets per month and never priced per agent, plus an AI Agent add-on charged per conversation the model resolves on its own. The exact per-conversation rate depends on your tier and billing cycle, so compare against a current quote, not a remembered blog rate. So “leaving Gorgias” usually means one of two different projects: replacing the helpdesk your humans work in, or replacing the AI layer that answers shoppers while nobody is watching. Matching the wrong replacement to the wrong job is the most common mistake in this category.
TL;DR: Leaving Gorgias starts with naming the job: are you replacing the ticket-and-inbox helpdesk for your team, or the AI agent that defuses volume? The costly part of any move is preserving order context, macros, customer profiles, and refund or return actions. Order-native tools (YourGPT, Chatbase, Tidio) and general desks (Zendesk, Freshdesk, Intercom) differ in billing and Shopify depth. If your volume is mostly order status and returns, test those flows before choosing.
Gorgias’s current billing has two meters, and both can fire on the same conversation. A helpdesk ticket fee applies to any ticket with at least one message sent from your desk, whether by an agent, the AI, or an automatic rule. An automation fee applies when the AI, or a Flow or order-management feature, resolves an inquiry without a human stepping in. The billing documentation is explicit that a ticket fully resolved by the AI can carry both fees: a ticket fee plus an automation fee. You are charged only the ticket fee when the AI hands over, and only the automation fee when a non-AI automation resolves the case.
Plan sizes scale with ticket volume, from roughly 50 to 5,000 tickets per month on the published tiers, with overage fees per extra ticket. The documentation’s worked example shows a plan including 300 tickets at $60 per month with $0.40 charged for each additional ticket. AI Agent is billed per resolved conversation, and the per-interaction rate varies by tier and by whether you are on annual or monthly billing. Ask your account team for the current plan configuration that matches your volume before you build a spreadsheet. Accounts created before May 28, 2025 that have not upgraded to Shopping Assistant skills stay on legacy pricing, where a conversation counts as either a ticket or an automation, not both. If you are on legacy pricing, your numbers will not match the current page, and neither will the alternatives you compare against.
None of this tells you which tool to buy. It tells you what you are actually replacing. A per-ticket meter funds the desk; a per-resolution meter funds the automation. A competitor that looks cheaper on the sticker may still bill you per seat or per message credit, so the comparison only works when units line up.
A helpdesk replacement needs a shared inbox, macros, routing rules, SLAs, customer profiles, and reports your team already depends on. An AI-layer replacement needs a knowledge base, a channel widget, and ideally permission to act on systems like Shopify. Some tools offer both; some offer one and ask you to bolt on the other.
Whatever you choose, take an inventory before you migrate. Gorgias’s Shopify integration shows how tied to order context the experience is: customer profiles with order history inside the ticket, order lookup without asking the shopper to repeat information, order management directly from the helpdesk, and macros that insert customer variables. When you move, the assets that genuinely need to travel are:
Ask each vendor how these export or import. A tool that looks capable in a demo can still leave you re-typing macros and losing order history.
One more thing belongs on the checklist: how the replacement authenticates shoppers. Typing an email address or order number is a lookup key, not proof of identity. Any tool that shows customer records or performs refunds should require a signed-in customer session or a server-validated flow, then enforce object-level permissions on each request. If a candidate asks shoppers to paste order numbers into chat and then acts on them, that is a security gap, not a convenience.
If your queue is mostly order status, shipping, and returns, the replacement needs to reproduce the order-aware behavior, not just answer questions.
YourGPT documents native store actions that run inside the chat: product search, product cards with price and variant selection, product details, add-to-cart, and view cart. These actions activate when the widget runs on a Shopify store and require Agent Mode. Enabling the actions integrates the widget with your storefront, but it does not grant the agent every Admin API permission; write access to order and customer data needs its own scoped setup. The help article describes the five actions in detail. The homepage claims order-status and return handling, but that is a documented product claim, not a verified action path; test it in your trial before relying on it. Pricing is a credit pool with a model-dependent consumption rate, so a heavy reasoning model burns credits faster than a lightweight one. Essential is $39 per month billed annually ($59 monthly) with 10 million credits and two bots; Professional is $79 annual ($129 monthly) and adds the AI helpdesk, functions, and human escalation; Advanced is $349 annual ($499 monthly). Credits are not the same unit as Gorgias’s or Chatbase’s message counts, so estimate against your actual response sizes and model choice.
Chatbase lists Shopify as an included integration even on its entry-level Hobby plan, which costs $32 per month billed annually ($40 monthly) and includes 700 message credits. The Basic plan at $120 annual ($150 monthly), 4,000 credits, adds the helpdesk inbox, voice, API access, and deeper integrations. Business at $400 annual ($500 monthly) covers 15,000 credits, advanced analytics, and tickets as a source. Chatbase supports actions beyond answering, including escalation, Slack, Stripe, Calendly, lead collection, web search, and custom API actions. Verify the exact Shopify scopes you need: the pricing page shows Shopify as a deployment and source channel, while deeper order mutations may require custom actions or API configuration. For custom actions, plan for the current Shopify app setup: since January 1, 2026, new custom apps are created through the Dev Dashboard or Shopify CLI, not through an admin-generated token.
Tidio has native Shopify actions as part of its feature set. Its pricing is conversation-based: Starter is $24.17 per month billed annually with 100 billable conversations, Growth starts at $49.17, and Plus starts at $300 plus monthly usage. A billable conversation is one in which a human agent replies or initiates, so AI-only traffic does not drive that meter. Lyro, its AI agent, is sold separately from $32.50 per month and can also run as a stand-alone product on another helpdesk such as Zendesk or Salesforce.
A useful sanity check is to build a small trial flow in the shortlist tool and run three tickets: a status lookup, a return request, and a refund edge case. If the tool cannot confirm the action and instead sends a templated “we’ll get back to you,” you have not replaced Gorgias; you have added a deflection layer in front of a queue.
The video above is Gorgias’s own walkthrough of its AI Agent handling Shopify tickets; it is useful for defining the baseline your replacement must match.
If you are leaving because you are not primarily a Shopify store, or because your tickets span products, B2B accounts, and internal teams, a general helpdesk is a scope change, not a like-for-like swap. The billing model flips from per-ticket to per-seat, and Shopify order context becomes work you must configure.
Zendesk sells per-agent plans. Suite Team is $55 per agent per month billed annually and includes AI agents; the AI billing unit is an automated resolution, meaning a customer request successfully resolved without escalation. Suite Professional is $115 per agent per month. Zendesk is a broad platform with a large marketplace and API, but the pricing documentation does not detail order-level Shopify actions in the core product. Plan for an app, connector, or custom API build to reproduce Gorgias-style order surgery.
Freshdesk is also per-agent. Growth is $19 per agent per month billed annually, Pro is $55, and Enterprise is $89. The Freddy AI Agent is included on every paid plan for the first 500 sessions, with additional sessions at $49 per 100. Freshdesk’s email AI session is defined as a 72-hour window, not one resolved ticket, so read the session definition before comparing automation volume.
Intercom splits seats and AI. Essential is a promotional $19 per seat per month with a struck-through $29, and the promotion’s conditions are not public. Fin, the AI agent, costs $0.99 per outcome on top of seats. Fin can also run on its own against an existing helpdesk with no seat costs, a 50-outcomes-per-month minimum, and no platform fee. Outcomes include resolutions, procedure handoffs, disqualifications, and self-serve routing at $0.99, while sales qualification outcomes are $9.99. Fin’s own integration list includes Gorgias, so it is a realistic AI-layer option even if you keep your current desk.
A small illustrative comparison, not a vendor benchmark: a three-person team with 1,200 tickets a month and an 80% automation rate would pay for roughly 960 automated outcomes. On Fin’s existing-helpdesk pricing that is about $950 before any seat cost, versus a seat-based suite at $55 per agent per month plus automated-resolution usage. Neither is universally cheaper; the team size, channels, and automation depth decide. Run the math with your own numbers.
Stay if the order workflow is already deeply configured and your complaint is the list price. The order context, macros, rules, and revenue reporting you rely on are hard to move, and an overage rate can often be solved by upgrading a tier or switching to annual billing rather than by rebuilding.
Stay if you operate multiple Shopify stores in one account and need the consolidated view, since several alternatives charge per project or per agent and may fragment your profile across stores.
Stay if you are entering peak season. Even a fast migration carries a learning curve; test alternatives while you are stable, then move when the queue is calm.
Switch when the mismatch is structural: your AI overage rate will not come down at any tier, you need channels Gorgias does not cover, you are not a store, or the AI layer you want is cheaper to run on a lightweight bot with a smaller ticket footprint.
The most common wrong move is choosing a tool that answers well but cannot act safely. Replay this exact exchange during your trial: a shopper writes “my order hasn’t arrived and I want a refund.” In Gorgias, the AI can look up the order, respond with status, and, if it resolves the conversation, that resolution is billed as automation. A knowledge-only bot will answer with policy text and then either leave the customer dangling or quietly create a ticket.
Three checks reveal the difference:
Also test the edge cases: a wrong item delivered, a partial refund, a cancellation that has already been fulfilled, and a pre-sale sizing question that should be answered, not escalated. If the tool fails on the order mutations, no knowledge-base quality will save it for your store. For asynchronous operations, confirm the tool tracks pending or failed jobs rather than treating a timeout as success.
| If your tickets are mostly | Your best fit is | Why |
|---|---|---|
Order status, shipping, returns | Gorgias renewal, YourGPT, Tidio, or Chatbase | Native or documented order actions, shop-aware context, and verifiable scope setup |
Mixed product support, non-Shopify | Zendesk or Freshdesk | Mature ticket routing, SLA, and per-agent pricing |
High automation with a small team | Intercom Fin standalone | Outcome billing with a 50-outcome minimum and no seat cost |
Simple FAQ deflection, no order data | YourGPT chatbot tier | Light setup, credit-based pricing, fast deployment |
This table is guidance, not a ranking: every row depends on your channel mix and on testing the order actions before contract. For YourGPT specifically, cart and search actions are documented; order-status and returns are claimed on the homepage and must be verified in a trial before you rely on them. For Chatbase, confirm the exact Shopify scopes your actions need.
Name the job first. If the problem is the AI overage, negotiate the tier or billing cycle before you migrate. If the problem is that your team works in a generic helpdesk and you just want better automation, Fin-style outcome pricing or a credit-based agent can sit on top of what you already have. If the problem is that Gorgias is not built for your business, pick a general desk and budget for integration work. And if the problem is that your tickets are order-heavy, test the order action flows in any candidate before you sign anything. A replacement that cannot complete a refund or confirm an order did not replace Gorgias; it just moved the queue, and a replacement that treats an email as proof of identity is a liability no matter how fluent its answers are.
Does Gorgias still sell the old $50 plan? No. Current helpdesk plans scale from 50 to 5,000 tickets per month and are never priced per agent, with AI Agent billed separately per resolved interaction. Per-interaction rates vary by tier and billing cycle, so ask for a quote that matches your volume. The legacy pricing model that billed one fee per conversation applies only to accounts created before May 28, 2025 that have not yet upgraded.
Can I replace just the AI layer and keep my helpdesk? Yes. Intercom Fin runs as a standalone product on other helpdesks, including Gorgias, at $0.99 per outcome with a 50-outcomes-per-month minimum and no seat costs. YourGPT and Chatbase also deploy as chat agents beside existing desks, though their credits and message units differ from Gorgias’s resolution meter.
Which alternative can actually cancel orders or issue refunds? Only tools with verified action connectors and a sound identity flow. YourGPT documents Shopify store actions such as add-to-cart and view cart, which require Agent Mode; order-status and returns are claimed on its homepage but need trial verification. Chatbase lists Shopify as an included integration and supports custom API actions. For any tool, check the exact Shopify API scopes, confirm the shopper is authenticated and authorized, and test a refund or cancellation in the trial environment before trusting it.
Is Zendesk cheaper than Gorgias? It depends on headcount and automation. Suite Team is $55 per agent per month billed annually and bills AI usage per automated resolution, so a small team with high ticket volume may pay less than a per-ticket meter, while a large team with low volume will pay more. Model your own seats and resolution volume before switching.
What data survives the move from Gorgias? Macros, templates, customer profiles, and order history can often be exported or imported, but deep cross-tool order context and revenue statistics rarely transfer intact. Ask each vendor for import documentation and test a representative export before deciding. If a candidate cannot restore your macros and order history, weight that against its other advantages.
When should I stay on Gorgias? Stay when the order-aware workflows, macros, and revenue reporting are already built and your only complaint is an overage rate that a tier or billing change can fix, or when you run multiple Shopify stores in one account and need the consolidated profile view. Switch when the mismatch is structural: you are not a store, you need channels outside its coverage, or the AI cost will not come down at any tier.
Further reading
3 next jobs from this page. Named destinations, not a pile of related guides.
03
